Earlier this month Tim Hudson won the MLB Comeback Player of the Year award for the National League. A week ago he was awarded the Sporting News Comeback Player of the Year award, and today he wins another: the MLB Players Choice Comeback Player of the Year for the N.L.
I believe that all baseball awarding bodies have now agreed that Tim Hudson was the comeback player of the year for the National League.
0 recs | 30 comments
I wish troy glaus would have played well enough to win this.
joshmaurer - October 25, 2010
Me too. Troy had a chance for this award in June. It’s too bad that his body didn’t hold up for him. By the way, I was in the stands for game four against the Giants and when Glaus came out of the game, I couldn’t help but wonder if he would get another chance to play in the majors. I hope he will get healthy and someone will give him a chance.
JimH - October 25, 2010
very thoughtful
I like Troy and hope he can return somewhere
Snorre - October 25, 2010
yeah, agreed
I feel that he is a good guy who works hard but his health issues plague him. I wish him the best of luck whatever happens to him.
saipol - October 26, 2010
Sacrilege
I know, but I wonder what kind of market Huddy’s contract would fetch.
Yakker - October 25, 2010
It depends on what kind of season we think he'd have next year to even consider trading him
I’d like him to retire a Brave because I love the guy. If I were making a top five fav. Braves list he’d be on it. Not that this means anything, lol
But what do you think we could get for him?
BravePhin - October 25, 2010
Tough to say
But I’d love for Wren to find out. Hudson outperformed his component stats this year, and he’s had issues with injuries in the past. Plus, he’s signed at a reasonable price for the next few years. As a fan, I’d love to see Hudson stay a Brave forever. However, he had exactly the sort of season that screams to be sold high.
Yakker - October 26, 2010
Thanks for that response
It makes sense. He IS near his end, and if we could somehow get a piece or two that would help us win in the future, it could be worth it.
BravePhin - October 26, 2010
Congratulations Huddy on a well-deserved award!
UMDBHIK - October 25, 2010
in other news don baylor signed 2 yrs with zona, so much for him as our hitting coach
Brandonba - October 25, 2010
Tim Hudson
Comebackiest Player of the Year
award6 - October 26, 2010
This headline reads like he has won CPOY three different times, to which I thought – is that a good thing? Thanks for clarifying.
CharlotteChop - October 26, 2010
This.
king of games - October 26, 2010
Congrats to Hudson. That is one move by Frank Wren that worked out far better than I thought it would.
redwards95 - October 26, 2010
Tim Hudson.
He came back.
sddbaker - October 26, 2010
Vote Hudson November 2.
TheLetter2 - October 26, 2010
I approved this message.
sddbaker - October 26, 2010
And yet
We’ve got people here trying to push him out the door, using the same stale stuff about how his bubble is about to pop.
Sam Jethroe - October 26, 2010
A 250 BAIBP and 82% LOB screams for regression. There’s nothing stale about it.
And no, I’m hardly trying to push anyone out the door. But smart GMs don’t act like fans with emotional connections to players—they sell assets high and buy em low.
Yakker - October 26, 2010
10 and 5 rights...
He’d have to consent to the trade in order to get moved.
I.E. he’s not going anywhere, unless it’s to help the team in the final year of his contract and we’re out of the postseason race.
-C
cthabeerman - October 27, 2010
He's signed through 2012 with an option for 2013
But good point on 10-and-5. I’d still see what interest there is for him.
Yakker - October 27, 2010
A regression from there...
could still leave him as our veteran horse leading the way for the kids. Don’t forget we’ve got a lot of talented young arms on the way up, and it’s a benefit in their development to have someone like Hudson to turn to on the bench beside them for advice. Add in that for Hudson, those numbers are more a strong season from him than some abnormal extreme luck season, and I don’t see the Braves looking to deal him. Maybe someone comes in with an offer that we just can’t turn down, but that doesn’t seem likely.
Mr. Sanchez - October 28, 2010
It's stale
In the sense that we read it here all year long and none of the predictions ever came to pass. Most people in that situation will take a step back and stop boldly predicting the same thing. Either than or you just keep saying it until it comes true, no matter how much later that is and declare that you knew it all along.
And please spare me the wised up bullshit about how good GM’s are Tuffminded. That’s stale, as well.
Sam Jethroe - October 27, 2010
Consider yourself spared, hoss
Yakker - October 27, 2010
I'm forever grateful.
Sam Jethroe - October 27, 2010
Hudson
Is a 10/5 guy, he would have to approve any trade, and having signed a relitively team friendly contract, I don’t think he would approve that.
bighop - October 27, 2010
The yearly salary was probably a bit below market, but at the time the length was not. Remember that when Huddy signed his $28M/3 deal, he was coming off major elbow surgery. In retrospect, he looked healthy in 2010 (and he’d pitched a bit at the tail end of 2009 to give the Braves some info), but it was still a gamble by the Braves to lock him up a 34-year old coming off major surgery for 3 years. Sheets, Harden, Bedard, etc. all only got 1 year, I believe.
I don’t think the guaranteed length of the deal should be ignored when considering whether Hudson took a “relatively team-friendly contract.”
Yakker - October 27, 2010
Bedard and Harden...
Both got one-year deals with mutual options on a second year. Both also had a much greater injury history than Hudson, as did Sheets.
-C
cthabeerman - October 27, 2010
Whether it was “team friendly” at the time might be debatable. After his 2010 season, it is “team friendly” in my eyes. Hudson wanted to be a Brave, the Braves wanted Hudson to be their pitcher. Win-Win. Chipper did it for years, he knew where he wanted to be and signed contracts that allowed it to happen. Unbelievably, for $20M per year less than A-Rod makes. McCann seems to be going the same route. Diaz too.
Money matters more to some players, less to others. Hudson was making $15M per before the TJ surgery if memory serves. Signing for $9M was a way to stay where he wanted. No more, no less.
bighop - October 27, 2010
Exactly.
Not everything (or everybody) fits into a set of neatly defined cubbyholes.
With that as the background of his contract, Wren trading (or even shopping) him would likely be seen as a major betrayal and would probably impact future signings.
Sam Jethroe - October 27, 2010
You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Talking Chop to post a comment.